mepeace.org

Are Humanistic Zionism, Humanistic Judaism, Humanistic Islam, or Humanistic Islamism possible?

Whether Humanistic Zionism, Humanistic Judaism, Humanistic Islam or Humanistic Islamism are possible may be worth exploring independently of other topics because some have questioned the related terminology some of us use:

Some examples are :

1) John W. introduced the term Humanistic Zionism.
2) I refer to myself as being genetically and neurotically Jewish

Here is some background information that I trust is not controversial:
I've added some subtopics for threads. Please add your own if you want a special topic for what you want to discuss.

Views: 159

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I left out Christianity really mainly because the subject line was getting too long. :-)

I also think that the word Humanism alone describes what many may think of as Humanistic Christianity. I see Humanism (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanism) simply as the deity-free version of what many refer to as the Judeo-Christian body of concepts and values (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judeo-Christian).
I've responded to this below. I hope you don't mind. :-)

I just wanted to try to structure the discussions.
Mary, two issues. The first is that clearly Zionism did not require the removal of people given both the fact that 20% of Israeli society is Arab, given the place the Arab population has in Israel's Declaration of Independence (you have read the Declaration, haven't you?), and the fact that one of Israel's two official languages is Arabic. How can anybody who has read that declaration see anything but Humanism? So again, have you read it, and what did you see it to be saying?

My second issue is with your abuse of the word "indigenous" which is defined as "originating where it is found" and is a matter of "geographic origin" as for the word "native". The "geographic origin" of all Arabs is the Arabian Peninsula, the "geographic origin" of Jews is Palestine (or Judea/Samaria). "Indigenous" can only be accurately used for Jews as they are native to Palestine. "Palestinians" are people who have called the area "home" for varying periods of time, some long, some short ... few longer than a couple of centuries if my research is correct, but that's neither here nor there. They are anything but "indigenous".

What is important is that there was no "removal of people" inherent in Zionism, and even the extremely right-wing Jabotinski (ideologically today's Likud) was committed to sharing with the Arab population.

The only thing you got right is that "Zionism is a political construct" ... it is a construct intrinsic to Judaism and has been for all of the thousands of years that Jews have considered themselves in "Exile", starting with the prophet Jeremiah's "If I forget thee O Jerusalem may my right hand lose its skill and my tongue cleave to my palate" that has been repeated in daily prayers since. So whilst Zionism doesn't need Judaism, it does need Jews, and Judaism does need it, therefore, contrary to your claim, it does "need to be related to Judaism".
Is Secular Judaism possible?

Discuss...
There some information about one attempt to formalise Secular Judaism at the website of The Society for Humanistic Judaism (http://www.shj.org/)
Other terms used for (deity-free) SecularJudaism are Humanistic Judaism and Secular Humanistic Judaism .
I think yes. I think that I am one such person. The synagogue I don't go to is orthodox. It is nearby. I feel that I am a member of that Jewish community.

I see myself as an agnostic, who is genetically and neurotically Jewish.

WHY?

Agnostic because I have no faith in a deity and I think that for most people G-d is just their name for what they don't know. I'd like to know. But I accept that I don't and will never know everything I want to know.

Genetically because my mother was Jew. So was my father, but the tradition and culture does not require that.

Neurotically because that was the environment in which I grew up, the stories I heard, the culture I learned, the values I acquired... The tribe/group to which I feel I belong and which accepts me as a member, the tribe of my ancestors, the sacred memory of the hundreds of near relatives I lost in the Shoah... And many other rational and irrational reasons...
Is Secular Islam possible?

Discuss...
Can anyone be a Secular Jew?

Discuss...
Is Secular Islamism possible?

Discuss...
Is Secular Zionism possible?

Discuss...
Is Humanistic Zionism possible?

Discuss...

RSS

Translate mepeace.org

Latest Activity

Shefqet Avdush Emini updated their profile
Monday
jen brown posted a blog post
Nov 28, 2018
Greg shaw and Jameelah are now friends
Nov 21, 2018
Jameelah updated their profile
Nov 20, 2018
Jameelah is now friends with sara bechor and Oliver Haack
Nov 20, 2018
Profile IconMaria Grispou and jen brown joined mepeace.org
Nov 15, 2018
Mohammad Suhail Bhat joined a group
Thumbnail

Indo-Pak Peace Forum

This group will be a forum for Indians and Pakistanis as well as for those who support Indo-Pak…See More
Nov 7, 2018

Search mepeace.org

"Like" us on Facebook

Promote MEPEACE online

Badge

Loading…

© 2019   Created by Eyal Raviv. Supported by One Region, One Future.   ..

Feedback | Report an Issue  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service