Recently Israel's Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman caused yet another blunder for Israel's foreign image in a series of hawkish comments and threats toward Syria. Following the diplomatic breech with Turkey by Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon, Israel has allowed its foreign policy to be poorly misrepresented by ideologues that differ greatly from the majority of Israelis who want peace. As the US finally announced that it is reinstating an ambassador to Syria, Israel needs to consider some gestures to ease the negative attention it has received and start looking to the North to resolve its own disputes with Syria. 

Turkey has recently reiterated its interest in resuming its mediating role between Israel and Syria. Israel should embrace the Turkish efforts and commit itself to a negotiated peace agreement with Syria, as the effects of this would reverberate throughout the region, especially as Iran continues to strengthen its ties to proxies Hezbollah and Hamas. Though the recent rift between Turkey and Israel over Israel's handling of Gaza has put a strain on the countries' bilateral relations, Turkey remains Israel's most important strategic ally in the region and is still in the best position to mediate between the two countries. The Israeli concerns over Turkey's ability to remain neutral in its mediating efforts do not take into account the progress that Turkish mediators were able to achieve in the last round of negotiations that collapsed with Operation Cast Lead. 

Turkish interests can be served only by being an honest broker, knowing full well that peace will not be made at the expense of Israel's national security interests. Israel must understand that Turkey's regional role, position and strategic objectives are changing but these changes are not contrary to the bilateral strategic relations between the two countries. Israel can benefit from a Turkish ally who is close to the Arab world. Turkey seeks Israeli-Syrian peace not merely for self-aggrandizement, but because for Turkey, a regional peace has a tremendous effect on its own national security and economic developments and will certainly have even greater impact on Israel's national security and economic interests. 

Looming beyond the benefits of direct Israeli-Syrian land-for-peace negotiations are the long-term implications this would have on Syria's ties with Iran and its proxies Hezbollah and Hamas. If Syria feels it is within reach of getting the Golan Heights and normal relations with the US, it takes no special acumen to understand that an Israeli-Syrian peace will fundamentally change Damascus' strategic interests and the geopolitical condition in the Middle East. Changing Syria's strategic interests will have a direct impact on Iran, Hamas and Hezbollah's behavior. Syria has served as the linchpin between the three and by removing Syria's logistical and political backing, which will inadvertently result from an Israeli-Syrian peace, Hamas and Hezbollah will be critically weakened. Both Hamas and Hezbollah are direct by-products of the Israeli occupation, and only by ending its hold on the Golan will Israel be in a position to begin effectively to deal with Arab extremism. Peace with Syria will change the center of gravity of Syrian politics in the region, which is shaped by Damascus' strategic interests. 

Whereas Israel's concerns over Iran's nuclear program may not be completely mitigated by an Israeli-Syrian peace, it will certainly force Tehran to rethink its strategy toward Israel. The irony is that while Israel continues to hype up the Iranian nuclear threat, and perhaps for good reason, it has lost focus on how to change the regional geopolitical dynamic and weaken Iran's influence in the region. Peace with Syria will under any circumstances reduce the prospect of using force against Iran to resolve its nuclear threat. However, under any violent scenario between Israel and Iran, Tehran will no longer be able to count on the almost automatic support of Hamas and Hezbollah because the national interests of these two groups will now be at odds with Syria's strategic interest. 

Israel must seize the opportunity to enter into negotiations with Syria not only because it can now negotiate from strength but also because of the collective Arab will to make peace as enunciated time and again by the Arab Peace Initiative. Israel cannot make the claim that it seeks peace but then fail to seize the opportunity when one is presented. President Bashar al-Assad, like his father, has prioritized peace with Israel as a strategic option. He has expressed time and again his desire to conclude a deal in exchange for the Golan Heights and a healthy relationship with the US. Israel must make a choice. It cannot continue trying to justify the occupation in the name of security when the whole Arab world is extending its hand to achieve a genuine peace. Israel must choose between territory and real security; as long as Syria has territorial claims against Israel, Israel will never be secure on its northern borders. If Syria offers peace, normalization of relations, and meets Israel's legitimate security concerns and Israel still refuses, the Golan will become a national liability rather than national security asset. 

The international opposition to Israel's continued occupation is growing because occupation of Arab land and the settlements is seen as the single source of continued regional strife and instability. Linking the occupation to national security concerns is viewed as nothing more than a pretext to maintain the occupation and as a recipe not only for self-isolation but a precursor for renewed violence. Indeed, even Israel's allies no longer buy into the linkage between territory and national security. It is time for Prime Minster Netanyahu to put an end to his Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman's reckless statements about Syria and lack of any diplomatic savoir-faire. The fact that the Israeli government is ideologically polarized offers no excuse for this kind of behavior that could result in an unintended violence that neither side wants. If Israel is truly focused on national security then it must relinquish the Golan Heights, because only a real peace with normal relations can offer Israel ultimate security. 

The fact that Syria chose a negotiating venue through Turkey to regain the Golan, and may not be in a position to regain it by force, should not be taken by Israel as if it can indefinitely maintain the status quo without serious consequences. Syria has shown tremendous capacity to deny Israel peace with Lebanon and the Palestinians and can continue to do so for as long as Israel occupies the Golan. Netanyahu needs to decide if he wants peace and what sort of coalition government he should assemble to meet the Israeli majority's yearning to end the conflict. The quality of governance and what message he wants to sent to the world rests with him. He cannot shirk this responsibility by blaming it on his fractured government. 

The appointment of Robert Ford as the new American ambassador to Syria has potential to open a new chapter in US-Syrian relations. Whereas the Obama administration is fully keen on trying to advance the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, it has no illusion that the real game changer in the Middle East in connection with Iran, Iraq, Lebanon and the Palestinians is an Israeli-Syrian peace. The Improved relations between the United States and Syria will inadvertently shift Syria's strategic calculus as the normalization of relations with the US and the prospect of regaining the Golan Heights will assume national priority over other tactical ties that Syria currently has with Iran, Hezbollah and Hamas. 

The United States will have to remain relentless in its efforts to advance the Israeli-Syrian peace and may find Turkey to be the best interlocutor between the two nations. 

Views: 66

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

In my view there will be no peace if there is no concessions, and Israel refuses to give any concessions that would reduce its influence in the region .
but dose Israel is giving priority to the peace process in the region .

From my perspective I do not think this??
Hi Alon

once again its all common sense but posting it on MEPEACE where everybody already know what needs to be done is a little bit of a waist.

I will pass it along some other sites as well if you do not mind

can I ask you for a favor?

I am a democrat ... not in the american party kind of way but in a way that I truly believe in democracy as a system .

saying the things that you say on meppeace, helps no one other then your own entreatment .

why don't you write to the white house and demand them to stop the support to Israel . ask them for answers ...

you have the power

I can only say that you will do avigdor liberman a huge favor ,
as an Israeli I can also tell you that I think that the current relationship btw Israel and the US does not work .
it serves only American interest.

Israel and the US has a lot in common and they are natural allies more then any other country in the world.
but I don't think that the current partnership is productive , America promoting American interests in the region on the account of Israel and other countries , in the mean while this system promotes anti semitism and hurt Israeli interests
P.S entreatment = entertainment
Dvid you do have the power .

don't blame it on conspiracies and ghosts . it is all up to you , be the change .

blaming a jewish lobby is giving your president a slack were you should not give him a slack.

take responsibility
David Crier, I think the Gaza crisis has proved how UN-unified the Arab world. Ask Gazans, how much did the Arab world do to help them? A: Zilch. "The Greatest Arab Country", Egypt, has gone out of its way to help Israel. PA President Mahmoud Abbas was telling Israel to hit harder. Did Hezbollah do anything during the Gaza war? One rocket which they denied was fired by their own people. Yes, Israel has "allies" only among two Arab governments, but the fact that the Arab world hates Israel is nothing new and doesn't help peace.
David, I didn't say anything about Jewish people. Though, a recent poll was recently published showing that around 90+% of Arabs in Israel's neighbors have negative view of Jews. Only about a third of Israeli Arabs have a negative view of Jews, and about half have a positive view of Jews.

So I guess we don't agree. During the Cold War, millions of Russians immigrated to the US. That conflict did not transform into ethnic animosity. There is no rationality to allow conflict to transform into ethnic animosity. Yet there is numerous evidence that the Israeli Arab conflict raised prejudice among the general Arab public, and among the Israeli right-wing.
both the ottoman occupiers and the British occupiers did not let any one fight .
there where some riots always but both empires knew how to control the people.

the jewish comunity in jeruslam over the years learned how to deal with occupiers and mostly wanted to be left alone

you also ignores many other factors in this argument. and of course the real need for a jewish home land in the world.
I absolutely agree with your link
the power is not in AIPAC lobby but in the american government .

and if lobbies have too much power in the states then you MUST fight against it .

I still think that giving your government a slack is wrong .
I agree that we must deal with Syria, Israel and Palestine together. The question remains who is pulling the punches for Syria. During the Iraqi War the key position of Syria was very challenged. They couldn't really say what they wanted. The existance of Russia to Iran and the fact that the Israel underground has used Russian groups that are curtailing media. This says a lot being the fact information from the white house is being channelled to the lobbiest groups who pay outsiders to do their work. They are indeed strong. Lets keep in mind who doesn't support Geneva convention.

To improve relations we need a full voice to the varied groups. Strong Ambassadors are a key to bringing in the position of proposed programs. Without good ambassadors there is little we can do to bring public relations of varied countries into the senior.

I have told the white house what I think about unfair lobbiests. Sometimes life isn't really fair. Morality is a state of mind to the group that is trying to pass a program. Legality is only a minor fraction to achieving success. Changing the valitiy of the law and rendering it useless like with the Russian hackers to Georgia rendering the government at stand still to the Whitehouse just allows us a new tatical measure to media warfare.
ok before this thread becoming a weird conspiracy "evil jews" discussion

I would say how the Israeli public sees the Golan.

in the Golan there is no "occupation" per say , no arab population no check points and no military.

the golan was occupied form Syria during the 6 days war,
when Syria held the golan they used the place constantly to attack Israelis and many many Israelis were slaughtered during that time

the golan has a huge importance to Israel both in security and economically.

yet today syria does not really pose a threat to Israel , Israel is much much stronger but.... syria does have a key role with Iran and lebanon .

syria has a huge interest to be open to the west and I think all these things in combination makes a huge interest for Israel and for the region, much more then keeping the golan

I actually think that peace with syria is much easier and a very realistic goal for the very near future.

we will need a big PR thou BC Israelis loves the golan and too many young men died there before we won the 6 days war .

you need to remember that the Israelis that are living in the golan are mostly not extreme religious settlers like in west bank but "regular" Israelis , most of them are farmers many belong to the Israeli left



Latest Activity

Dr. David Leffler posted a blog post

Cruise Ships for Peace in The Middle East

By Teresa Studzinski, Arlene J. Schar, and Dr. David Leffler Variations of this article were…See More
Nov 6
Shefqet Avdush Emini updated their profile
Oct 29
Mauricio San Miguel Llosa updated their profile
Oct 4
Amir Salameh updated their profile
Jun 25
Fredda Goldfarb updated their profile
Apr 15
Dr. David Leffler posted a blog post
Apr 9


"Like" us on Facebook

Promote MEPEACE online



© 2019   Created by Eyal Raviv. Supported by One Region, One Future.   ..

Feedback | Report an Issue  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service